Ferris Research Free News
Sunday, January 11, 2009
  Jan 9, Daily Compliance & Messaging News
Ferris Research Home

Sign up for the Ferris News Service here

News on messaging, content control, compliance, e-discovery, data leak prevention
Daily Digest: January 9, 2009
Content Control, Compliance, Archiving, E-Discovery, & Data Leak Prevention

Brown Rudnick LLP Improves Efficiency and Consolidates IT Costs with Mimecast  

Survey of Spam Control Products, and Survey of Archiving Products -- See what others think of these products/services. If you add your own data, we will send you a summary of the findings.

Capital One Selects Recommind for Information Management  
Comment on Recommind here

Blog Item(s)

IBM's Open Collaboration Client Solution Saves Money?

IBM recently presented its Open Collaboration Client Solution (OCCS), in conjunction with Virtual Bridges, to Ferris. IBM proposes that OCCS presents substantial cost savings over the equivalent Microsoft approach. We're skeptics.


  • IBM's OCCS is not a new product offering.
  • Rather, it is a bundling of existing Lotus products for Linux (Eclipse-based offerings, such as Notes 8.x, Sametime, and Symphony, and native Linux offerings such as Domino) under a new moniker.
  • Virtual Bridges provides software that supports Linux-hosted Windows (Win4VDI) and Linux (VERDE) virtual desktops.
  • Think of Win4VDI as Citrix-like functionality delivered atop Linux, as opposed to Windows, clusters.
  • VERDE is an analog to Win4VDI, delivering Citrix-like functionality for virtual Linux, as opposed to virtual Windows desktops, again atop Linux clusters.

At the heart of this offering is IBM's belief that customers are spending so much money on Microsoft licenses that there is none left to spend with other IT vendors, including IBM. This is a situation that IBM only expects to get worse in the current "credit crunch" and recession.

IBM proposes a five-level approach to eliminating or reducing Microsoft license payments:

  • Switch from an annual Microsoft Enterprise Agreement to "an only license when you upgrade" Microsoft Select Agreement licensing plan.
  • Replace Microsoft Office with Linux-based Lotus Symphony on the desktop.
  • Replace Windows Exchange Server + Office Communications Server (OCS) + SharePoint + Windows Server, with Lotus Domino Server (including Sametime) + Quickr Server atop Linux, on the back end.
  • Replace Windows with Linux on the desktop (real or virtual).
  • Replace PCs on the desktop or Citrix/Windows Terminal Servers with Virtual Bridge VERDE Linux clusters or IBM zSeries servers.

IBM claims that the first saving ($75 per user per annum) is achieved by only purchasing Microsoft software licenses under a Microsoft Select Agreement when installing new Microsoft software (every 3-5 years), rather than entering into an Microsoft Enterprise Agreement and paying an annual license fee. This analysis is based on list prices. This is a false argument. In practice, organizations are able to negotiate Microsoft Enterprise Agreements that eliminate this $75 per user per annum differential.

For many years, competitors (Corel Office, Lotus SmartSuite) have offered productivity suites at significantly lower price points than Microsoft Office. For some time, Star Office-derived offerings (Open Office from Sun, and more recently, Symphony from IBM/Lotus) have been available at zero cost. We accept that there are users who do not need the power (and attendant complexity) of Microsoft Office. However, these alternative offerings have had little impact on Microsoft's Office market share.

IBM's approach also involves a hidden cost. Lotus Symphony is written in Java and runs atop Lotus Expediter and open-source Eclipse, also written in Java. Under Windows and Linux, Java JAR files are treated as data, which considerably increases the memory footprint of these applications. In fact, Lotus recommends at least 1GB of memory to run Symphony effectively. Business users who wish to migrate desktop PCs from Microsoft Office to Lotus Symphony may find that they will need to upgrade (replace?) these PCs at significant cost. In fairness to IBM, users who wish to upgrade to Windows Vista will also require a significant PC upgrade.

Ferris is very dubious about any cost savings that accrue from replacing Microsoft Exchange + SharePoint + OCS with Lotus Domino + Quickr + Sametime, or vice versa. In both cases, Ferris data indicates that migration costs swamp any putative savings. In addition, as with IBM productivity applications (see above), upgrading to Notes 8.x, which is Java/Expediter/Eclipse-based, introduces a 1GB PC desktop RAM requirement. This is a requirement that is not satisfied by the vast majority of currently deployed business desktop PCs (see above). In addition, Ferris believes that any organizations that are willing to allow Microsoft to host their collaboration data will be able to realize considerable cost savings by switching to Microsoft's Online offering (see MS Exchange Online Pricing) of which Exchange Online + SharePoint Online + Office Communication Online + Live Meeting can be purchased for $15 per user per month.

Certainly, replacing Windows with Linux on the desktop can deliver significant license costs savings. In general, Ferris data shows that support costs swamp license fees on most business desktops. If a move to Linux on the desktop increases the support load by even a few percent, then this cost will more than swamp any license cost saving.

Finally, IBM has been at a disadvantage when competing with Microsoft Terminal Server- or Citrix-based hosted desktop solutions. Yes, IBM has had a zSeries mainframe-based hosted Linux offering, but for most customers this is not an option. By partnering with Virtual Bridges to offer hosted Linux desktops atop Linux clusters, IBM now has a more attractive offering. Unfortunately, because the majority of IBM desktop software is written in Java and runs atop Expediter/Eclipse, which are also written in Java, and because Java code is treated as data, no code sharing can be achieved. For example, every hosted desktop will require at least 1GB of dedicated memory. This inability to use shared code images, combined with a large memory footprint, will require more DRAM and thus more servers in an IBM solution than a Microsoft- or Citrix-hosted Windows desktop application server. This additional hardware + software cost may well nullify any putative license fee savings.

We cannot help but feel that IBM is today, as it has been for many years, interested in the idea of reducing Microsoft's desktop revenue. It has tried with mainframe-based offerings, with Java-based Network Computers, and now with its Linux-based Open Collaboration Client Solution. IBM has not succeeded in the past, nor do we expect it to be any more successful with this offering. In our opinion, the greatest threat to Microsoft's desktop hegemony comes from the cloud (e.g., Google Apps, etc.). We believe that Microsoft's rapidly emerging Live and Online offerings mean that Microsoft is already well positioned to benefit from any move to the cloud, just as it did with an earlier move to the browser and Web server. ... Nick Shelness



Recent Research

Recent Reports Available:

For more reports, visit our reports page.

Recent Ferris Webcasts:

About Ferris Research

Ferris Research studies messaging, and the control of electronic information. More specifically, we help IT staff evaluate and implement products and services that:

  • Provide messaging and collaborative technologies
  • Archive electronic information
  • Ensure compliance with corporate policy, industry regulations, and laws
  • Facilitate e-discovery, and contain its costs
  • Reduce the dangers of information leaks

Email is the most important type of electronic information that requires control today. Other important types include instant messages, Sharepoint teamspaces, images, voice, video, and miscellaneous desktop files.

We've been in business since 1990--longer than any other analyst firm in our field:

  • Clients include 300 of the world's 1,000 largest organizations, and computer vendors from the largest corporations to small startups
  • While other analysts have come and gone, we've published more than 200 formal reports and 1,100 short bulletins
  • Our news service covers more than 2,000 highly specialized announcements annually
  • We have nine experts in our research team, sharing many decades of experience in our core competencies

In short, our technology and industry depth helps you understand today's products, where they've come from and where they're going.

Have news you want to share with us or product or interest area that you would like us to cover? Send press releases to releases@ferris.com.

Copyright © Ferris Research 2008.


Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home
Lets anyone with a professional interest in messaging and collaboration keep up with the news and key trends ... To sign up, go to www.ferris.com ... If you want a version that includes analysis of the news and puts everything in a single email, subscribe to our Analyzer Information Service ... Got some news you want to share with us? Send press releases and conference announcements relevant to messaging to releases@ferris.com ... Copyright © Ferris Research 2005-2006.

September 2005 / October 2005 / November 2005 / December 2005 / January 2006 / February 2006 / March 2006 / April 2006 / May 2006 / June 2006 / July 2006 / August 2006 / September 2006 / October 2006 / November 2006 / December 2006 / January 2007 / February 2007 / March 2007 / April 2007 / May 2007 / June 2007 / July 2007 / August 2007 / September 2007 / October 2007 / November 2007 / December 2007 / January 2008 / February 2008 / March 2008 / April 2008 / May 2008 / June 2008 / July 2008 / August 2008 / September 2008 / October 2008 / November 2008 / December 2008 / January 2009 / February 2009 / March 2009 / April 2009 / May 2009 / June 2009 / July 2009 / August 2009 / September 2009 / October 2009 / November 2009 / December 2009 / January 2010 / February 2010 / March 2010 / April 2010 / March 2011 / March 2012 /

Powered by Blogger